| 2026 | T. Cheevers (NIBA) | S. Swift (NIPGL) |
| 2025 | O. O’Brien (ILB) | T. Cheevers (NIBA) |
| 2024 | H. McFarland (NIBA) | O. O’Brien (ILB) |
| 2023 | B. Galloway (NIPGL) | H. McFarland (NIBA) |
| 2022 | C. Hogg (NIPBA) | B. Galloway (NIPGL) |
| 2021 | D. Dempsey (NIBA) | C. Hogg (NIPBA) |
| 2020 | D. Dempsey (NIBA) | D. Dempsey (NIBA) |
| 2019 | D. McCloy (NIPGL) | D. Dempsey (NIBA) |
| 2018 | M. Brophy (BLI) | D. McCloy (NIPGL) |
| 2017 | D. Forsythe (NIPGL) | M. Brophy (BLI) |
| 2016 | S. Moran (NIBA) | D. Forsythe (NIPGL) |
| 2015 | R. Madden(NIPBA) | S. Moran (NIBA) |
| 2014 | E. Whitten (NIBA) | R. Madden (NIPBA) |
| 2013 | R. Blair (NIPGL) | E. Whitten (NIBA) |
| 2012 | C. Ryan (BLI) | R. Blair (NIPGL) |
| 2011 | C. Wallace (NIBA) | C. Ryan (BLI) |
| 2010 | T. McIlvenna (NIPGL) | C. Wallace (NIBA) |
| 2009 | J. Moore (NIPBA) | T. McIlvenna (NIPGL) |
| 2008 | J. Humphreys (NIBA) | J. Moore (NIPBA) |
| 2007 | D.A. Graham, OBE (NIPGL) | J. Humphreys (NIBA) |
| 2006 | B. O’Malley (BLI) | D.A. Graham, OBE (NIPGL) |
| 2005 | A. Oliver (NIBA) | B. O’Malley (BLI) |
| 2004 | A.R. McKay (IBA) | A. Oliver (NIBA) |
| 2003 | N. Haffern (NIPGL) | A.R. McKay (IBA) |
| 2002 | R. Ross (NIPBA) | N. Haffern (NIPGL) |
| 2001 | C. Beck (NIBA) | R. Ross (NIPBA) |
| 2000 | H. Montgomery (NIPGL) | C. Beck (NIBA) |
| 1999 | B.C. Morton (BLI) | H. Montgomery (NIPGL) |
| 1998 | J. Donaldson (NIBA) | B.C. Morton (BLI) |
| 1997 | H. Cupples (NIPBA) | J. Donaldson (NIBA) |
| 1996 | C.E. Gillett (NIPGL) | H. Cupples (NIPBA) |
| 1995 | A. Murray (NIBA) | C.E. Gillett (NIPGL) |
| 1994 | W. Patton (NIPGL) | A. Murray (NIBA) |
| 1993 | J.G. Byrne (BLI) | W. Patton (NIPGL) |
| 1992 | R. Martin (NIBA) | J.G. Byrne (BLI) |
| 1991 | J. McCullough (PGL) | R. Martin (NIBA) |
| 1990 | S. Strange (NIBA) | J. McCullough (PGL) |
| 1989 | R.W. Bolton (PBA) | S. Strange (NIBA) |
| 1988 | E.J. Gordon (PGL) | R.W. Bolton (PBA) |
| 1987 | W.A. Gracey (NIBA) | E.J. Gordon (PGL) |
| 1986 | J.F. Quinn, BEM (PGL) | W.A. Gracey (NIBA) |
| 1985 | J.J. Burke (BLI) | J.F. Quinn, BEM (PGL) |
| 1984 | H. McBride (NIBA) | J.J. Burke (BLI) |
| 1983 | T.C. McGookin (PGL) | H. McBride (NIBA) |
| 1982 | W. Moreland (NIBA) | T.C. McGookin (PGL) |
| 1981 | J. Stevenson (PBA) | W. Moreland (NIBA) |
| 1980 | A.R. McKay (NIPGL) | J. Stevenson (PBA) |
| 1979 | J. Barnes (NIBA) | A.R. McKay (NIPGL) |
| 1978 | W. Caves (NIPGL) | J. Barnes (NIBA) |
| 1977 | R. Cinch (BLI) | W. Caves (NIPGL) |
| 1976 | S. Allen (NIBA) | R. Cinch (BLI) |
| 1975 | T. Sutton (PGL) | S. Allen (NIBA) |
| 1974 | W. Burrows (NIBA) | T. Sutton (PGL) |
| 1973 | J.W.S. Barr (NIPBA) | W. Burrows (NIBA) |
| 1972 | C. Clawson (PGL) | J.W.S. Barr (NIPBA) |
| 1971 | J. McNeice (NIBA) | C. Clawson (PGL) |
| 1970 | J.R. Stirling, MBE (PGL) | J. McNeice (NIBA) |
| 1969 | P. McGuirk (BLI) | J.R. Stirling, MBE (PGL) |
| 1968 | J.H. Graham (NIBA) | P. McGuirk (BLI) |
| 1967 | H.F. Lutton (PGL) | J.H. Graham (NIBA) |
| 1966 | R.S. Weir (Alexandra) | H.F. Lutton (PGL) |
| 1965 | John Thompson, MA, LLB (Limavady) | R.S. Weir (Alexandra) |
| 1964 | S.J. Thompson (Willowfield) | John Thompson (Limavady) |
| 1963 | J.S. Bell (Bangor) | S.J. Thompson (Willowfield) |
| 1962 | M.H. Henry, JP (Mossley) | J.S. Bell (Bangor) |
| 1961 | S. Wilson (Railway Union) | M.H. Henry, JP (Mossley) |
| 1960 | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) | S. Wilson (Railway Union) |
| 1959 | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) | S. Wilson (Railway Union) |
| 1958 | Simon Logan, MC (Pickie) | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) |
| 1957 | Simon Logan, MC (Pickie) | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) |
| 1956 | John Ferguson, JP (Donaghadee) | Simon Logan, MC (Pickie) |
| 1955 | Fred Allen (Albert Foundry) | John Ferguson, JP (Donaghadee) |
| 1954 | James Tully (Alexandra) | Fred Allen (Albert Foundry) |
| 1953 | John Gribbon, B.A. (Larne) | James Tully (Alexandra) |
| 1952 | A.S. McVicker (Ballycastle) | William Logan, OBE, JP (Banbridge) & John Gribbon, B.A. (Larne) |
| 1951 | James Conway (Woodvale) | A.S. McVicker (Ballycastle) |
| 1950 | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) | James Conway (Woodvale) |
| 1949 | Samuel Mitchell (Comber) | Thompson Ross (Ballynafeigh) |
| 1948 | H. Stewart (Whitehead) | Samuel Mitchell (Comber) |
| 1947 | Dr T.E. Hill (Salisbury) | S.J. Hardy & H. Stewart (Whitehead) |
| 1946 | D. Willix (Ormeau) | Dr T.E. Hill (Salisbury) |
| 1945 | W.J. Walker (Portadown) | D. Willix (Ormeau) |
| 1944 | Percy T. Watson (Ewarts) | W.J. Walker (Portadown) |
| 1943 | H. Hutton (Windsor) | Percy T. Watson (Ewarts) |
| 1942 | H.J. Staff (Kenilworth) | H. Hutton (Windsor) |
| 1941 | G. Browne, MBE (Ballymoney) | H.J. Staff (Kenilworth) |
| 1940 | Councillor J. Hopkins (Falls) | G. Browne, MBE (Ballymoney) |
| 1939 | William Coe (Ballymena) | Councillor J. Hopkins (Falls) |
| 1938 | R.F. McCartney, JP (Coleraine) | William Coe (Ballymena) |
| 1937 | A. Brown, JP (Belmont) | R.F. McCartney, JP (Coleraine) |
| 1936 | D.E. Gardiner (Belfast) | A. Brown, JP (Belmont) |
| 1935 | J. Patterson, JP (Mossley) | D.E. Gardiner (Belfast) |
| 1934 | James Boyd (Musgrave) | J. Patterson, JP (Mossley) |
| 1933 | J. McCormick, JP (Strand) | James Boyd (Musgrave) |
| 1932 | William Brown (Connsbrook) | J. McCormick, JP (Strand) |
| 1931 | J. McWhirter, JP (Victoria) | William Brown (Connsbrook) |
| 1930 | W.H. Scott, JP (Stewartstown) | J. McWhirter, JP (Victoria) |
| 1929 | Major William Baird, DL (Press) | W.H. Scott, JP (Stewartstown) |
| 1928 | Major William Baird, DL (Press) | W.H. Scott, JP (Stewartstown) |
| 1927 | Thomas H. Barr (Cliftonville) | Major William Baird, DL (Press) |
| 1926 | Major S.H. Hall-Thompson | Thomas H. Barr (Cliftonville) |
| 1925 | Robert Crawford (Ormo Bakery) | Major S.H. Hall-Thompson |
| 1924 | Wm McLean (North Belfast) | Robert Crawford (Ormo Bakery) |
| 1923 | Samuel Pink (Knock) | Wm McLean (North Belfast) |
| 1922 | T.W. McMullan, MP (Bangor) | Samuel Pink (Knock) |
| 1921 | Herbert E. Eaton (Castleton) | T.W. McMullan, MP (Bangor) |
| 1920 | Joseph Bradbury (Alexandra) | Herbert E. Eaton (Castleton) |
| 1919 | Joseph McMullen (Forth River) | Joseph Bradbury (Alexandra) |
| 1918 | W.J. Bell (Woodvale) | Joseph McMullen (Forth River) |
| 1917 | T.J. Kearney (Ballynafeigh) | W.J. Bell (Woodvale) |
| 1916 | Walter Irvine (Cavehill) | T.J. Kearney (Ballynafeigh) |
| 1915 | D.D. Young (Shaftesbury) | Walter Irvine (Cavehill) |
| 1914 | C. L. MacKean, JP (Larne) | D.D. Young (Shaftesbury) |
| 1913 | P. Sheridan (Ulster) | C. L. MacKean, JP (Larne) |
| 1912 | Dr John Rusk (Belfast) | P. Sheridan (Ulster) |
| 1911 | A. Dickson (Belmont) | J.B. Hamilton (Ballymoney) |
| 1910 | J. Hetherington (Falls) | G.W. Cooper (Kenilworth) |
| 1909 | W. McConnell (Ballymena) | J. Hetherington (Falls) |
| 1908 | John Gass (Ormeau) | J. Hetherington (Falls) |
| 1907 | Wm McLetchie (Belmont) | John Gass (Ormeau) |
| 1906 | Dr. J.R. Davison (Ulster) | Wm McLetchie (Belmont) |
| 1905 | D. MacLaughlin (Coleraine) | Dr. J.R. Davison (Ulster) |
